MADR

Details
Full Name

Markdown Architectural Decision Records

Core Concepts:

Structured template

Well-defined format with specific sections

Standard fields

  • Title (short noun phrase)

  • Status (proposed, accepted, rejected, deprecated, superseded)

  • Context and Problem Statement

  • Decision Drivers (forces influencing the decision)

  • Considered Options (alternatives evaluated)

  • Decision Outcome (chosen option with justification)

  • Pros and Cons of the Options (trade-off analysis)

  • Links (related decisions, references)

Markdown format

Uses standard Markdown for wide compatibility

Clear structure

More detailed than basic ADRs, includes explicit alternatives

Trade-off documentation

Explicitly captures pros/cons of each option

Version control

Stored with code, immutable like other ADRs

Lightweight yet comprehensive

Balances completeness with maintainability

Key Proponents

Oliver Kopp, Olaf Zimmermann (and MADR community)

Reference

https://adr.github.io/madr/

When to Use:

  • When you need more structure than basic ADRs

  • Projects requiring explicit documentation of alternatives

  • Teams that need to justify decisions with detailed trade-offs

  • Organizations using Markdown-based documentation workflows

  • When LLM assistance is needed to generate consistent decision records

  • Complementing arc42 Section 9 (Architecture Decisions)

Current Status:

  • The current release is MADR 4.0.0 (September 2024). The name changed twice along the way: MADR 3.x (2022) renamed "Markdown Architectural Decision Records" to "Markdown Any Decision Records"; 4.0 renamed it back, while keeping the template usable for any decision

  • An LLM’s training-data prior most plausibly reproduces the 2.x-era format (2018–2022, the longest-lived and most widely copied variant): inline * Status: / * Deciders: / * Date: bullets and split "Positive/Negative Consequences" sections — rather than the current YAML front matter with decision-makers, the merged "Consequences" section, and the "Confirmation" element introduced in 3.x/4.x

  • When the exact format matters, point the model at the current template or paste it into the prompt — the anchor name reliably evokes the concept, but not the current field set